Thursday, March 31, 2016

The new "funeral representative" law

The Michigan legislature has passed, and the governor has signed, Public Act 57 (2016), which includes amendments to section 3206 of the Estates and Protected Individuals Code (EPIC) governing the disposition of the remains of deceased persons. 

The previous list of priorities for making determinations was discussed in our April 2012 posting. A brief recap of those provisions:
  • The decedent could not control this issue, by will or otherwise.
  • The personal representative had no say, either, if he was not a family member. 
  • The determination would be made by the surviving spouse or, if none, a majority of the nearest relatives.
  • If they could not agree, the probate court could be asked to resolve the dispute.
The revised section 2306 adds a new "funeral representative" at the top of the list. The previous listed priority remains, but the first in line (absent a DOD designation as noted below) to make the decision about disposition, including cremation, is the decedent's designated "funeral representative."

How is that person named? The section provides
  • the funeral representative must be age 18 or old and of sound mind
  • the designation is to be made in writing, dated, and signed
  • the writing must be signed before two witnesses or a notary
  • the designation may be made as part of the person's will or Patient Advocate Designation, or it may be a self-standing writing
The following should also be noted.

If the designation of the funeral representative is made in the decedent's will, it does not have to be submitted to probate for the designation to be effective.

The previous provisions (discussed here previously) giving the very first priority to the person designated in Form DD-93, promulgated by the U.S. Department of Defense, for a decedent who was "a service member" at the time of his death will continue, with the subsections and their language reorganized to make the order of priority clearer. Deferral to the DOD form was necessary since that is a matter of Federal law.

A new provision is included as subsection 3-e:
"If an individual [designated in Form DD-93] had the right to dispose of the decedent’s body under subsection (1), but affirmatively declined to exercise his or her right or failed to exercise his or her right within 48 hours after receiving notification of the decedent’s death, the individual does not have the right to make a [later] decision about the disinterment of the decedent’s body or possession of the decedent’s cremated remains."

Sunday, February 7, 2016

Two estate recovery decisions

In In re Estate of Keyes, 310 Mich App 266; 871 NW2d 388 (2015), lv den, ____ Mich ____ (2016), the Court of Appeals held that estate recovery could proceed for the expenses paid for a nursing home admission which began in April 2010, even though the Medicaid beneficiary did not receive the notice required under MCL 400.112g-7 at that time. It was noted that the required information had been included in a May 2012 application. (The court did not specifically note the fact, but MDCH, the agency then administering the Medicaid program, required reapplication every year in order to continue Medicaid coverage. The notice was contained in the reapplication form beginning in 2012, it appears.) 

Last month, the Michigan Supreme Court denied leave to appeal, leaving this decision as established law in Michigan. 

In In re Estate of Gorney, ____ Mich App ____ (2016), issued as a published opinion by the Court of Appeals on February 4, 2016, the court addressed the question of whether the Department of Health and Human Services (which has been administering the Medicaid program since last year's reorganization) could properly assert estate recovery retroactive to July 2010. Gorney was the first named plaintiff in a consolidated appeal involving four different estates opened in four different counties. 

In Gorney, each of the four decedents began receiving Medicaid benefits to pay for long-term care after the estate recovery statute was enacted in 2007. Each of them received, in 2012, an application form for requalification for benefits which included the mandated notice language. In each case, after the death of the beneficiary, the Department sought to pursue estate recovery for benefits paid on and after July 1, 2010. (It is not stated in the opinion why the Department chose that date.) 

As in Keyes, each personal representative sought to invalidate the estate recovery claim based on the failure to provide the required notice when the beneficiary first qualified for Medicaid. The court ruled that Keyes had resolved that issue and rejected the appeals on that point. 

The personal representatives also argued that it was a violation of due process for the state to include benefits paid from July 2010. The evidence showed that the Department had sought Federal approval for its estate recovery program, as required under the Federal Medicaid laws and under the 2007 estate recovery statute, and that that approval was granted in May 2011. On July 1, 2011, the Department "implemented" the program for the first time by instructing its personnel to begin operating the program. 

The court partially agreed with the personal representatives on due process grounds. It found that the estate recovery program could go back to benefits paid from and after July 1, 2011, but could not do so for the one additional year going back to July 1, 2010. 

Thus, we now know that the estate recovery program can seek reimbursement from the estate of a decedent for benefits paid for long-term care services after July 2011, but not before. 

As with Keyes, look for the estates to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. 

Saturday, January 23, 2016

In case of emergency

A family dealing with a sudden illness or injury sustained by a loved one will not be thinking of all of his or her details, but they should keep track of bills as they are received and come due. They should make sure that utility bills are paid, propane tanks remain full, etc.

In particular, they should make sure that premiums on health insurance, life insurance, disability insurance, auto insurance, and homeowner's insurance are paid and kept current. For some of these coverages, keeping them in force will be of crucial importance to the affected person and his or her family.We have seen numerous cases where life insurance benefits that the family expected, and depended on, are not paid because the insured, due to lengthy illness before he died, allowed the policy to lapse for non-payment of the premium.

Sunday, January 3, 2016

Michigan estate recovery

The estate recovery program allows the State of Michigan, in some cases, to seek repayment of Medicaid benefits for nursing home care and home health care after the recipient has died.  Mandated by Federal law, estate recovery is essentially a tradeoff for the fact that the recipient's home is not included as a "countable asset" (if its value is under $500,000) when calculations are done to verify that the recipient has assets below the maximum allowed to qualify for Medicaid coverage.

In the majority of cases, for a couple of reasons, the only asset for which the estate recovery claim is asserted is the recipient's home.

Michigan's estate recovery statute, found at MCL 400.112g and 112h, allows for recovery only against "probate assets," that is, property owned by the decedent in his sole name which does not pass to others by operation of law, and for which it is necessary to open an estate in probate court. Property which passes under joint tenancy, for example, is not subject to estate recovery in Michigan. A home owned by husband and wife as tenants by the entirety is likewise not subject to estate recovery. (In other states, such as Wisconsin, jointly-held assets are also subject to the estate recovery laws.)

When the family home is included in the probate estate, there are several exemptions and limitations that are important. The first and most significant is that the home may not be subject to estate recovery if the surviving spouse is residing there. Further, there is a monetary limitation when that exemption does not apply. The home is subject to estate recovery only to the extent to which the price that it can be sold for by the personal representative exceeds
  • "50% of the average price of a home" in the county, plus
  • the costs of estate administration, funeral costs, etc., and
  • all applicable statutory exemptions
The exemptions that are allowed under statute include the homestead allowance, the family allowance, and exempt property. If all three apply, when the decedent leaves a surviving spouse, the total amount can be as high as $64,000, given the current applicable figures.

An unpublished decision of the Michigan Court of Appeals issued in 2015 ruled that the person seeking to apply the 50% average price limitation must take steps to apply for it, and must do so within the time that the department specifies. It will not be automatically available.

Today, eight years after estate recovery was enacted, and five years after it went into effect, there is still some uncertainty as to how "the average price of a home" in a given county can be calculated. There are a couple of online sources that can provide assistance on this issue.

If you have received an estate recovery notice, be sure to consult with an experienced attorney to ensure that the needed steps can be taken.

Thursday, December 10, 2015

2016 inflation adjustments announced

The IRS has issued its year-end update on adjustments to certain dollar limits for 2016.
  • The annual exclusion remains at $14,000. This is the maximum amount that one person can give to another person in one year without having to file a gift tax return. For gifts above that amount, a return must be filed but no gift tax is owed so long as the total reportable gifts by one person over his or her lifetime is less than the gift tax exemption amount.
  • The estate tax, gift tax, and generation-skipping exemption amounts are increased to $5.45 million for persons dying in 2016.

Sunday, November 8, 2015

The new MyRA

The U.S. Treasury Department has announced a new type of retirement savings program to encourage people to start retirement savings. The "MyRA" program is essentially an entry-level Roth IRA program. Money can be contributed or can be deducted from paychecks and maintained in an account with the Federal government, and the money will earn interest at the rate used for the Government Securities Program, reportedly 2.34% in 2014.

These are the differences between a standard IRA and the new MyRA vehicle:



IRA MyRA
Source Before-tax money After-tax money
Tax deduction Yes No
Limits $5,500 per year $5,500 per year
Withdrawals Subject to income tax Not subject to income tax – tax has already been paid
Early withdrawal 10% penalty before age 59.5 (as to earnings only) No penalty
Invested Any vehicle – CDs, stocks, bonds, mutual funds Governmental account paying interest
Can lose money Yes No

According to the regulation, issued by Treasury in December 2014, the custodian of the accounts will invest the proceeds in a new investment vehicle called "Retirement Savings Bonds" which will not be held by individual savers. Rather, they will be held by custodian. Interestingly, there has been no announcement of who that custodian will be.

When the amount in the account reaches $15,000, or after the individual has participated for 30 years, whichever comes first, eligibility is at an end, and the individual will then be required to move the funds to a Roth IRA sponsored by a bank, credit union, or financial adviser.

Thursday, October 22, 2015

Recheck your beneficiary designations

Most people who have money in tax-deferred retirement accounts such as IRAs or 401-k plans know that it is important to name a designated beneficiary (DB) and a contingent beneficiary (CB) for those plans. The Federal statutes that govern these plans provide:
  • The account will be payable to the DB and can be paid out over the DB's life expectancy.
  • The account will be payable to the CB in the same fashion if the DB dies before the owner of the account.
  • If there is no DB or CB, the account is payable as the plan documents direct, and that may be to the estate of the owner.
  • If there is no proper DB/CB, the entire amount in the account must be distributed, as taxable income, within five years of the owner's death.
  • The owner's spouse must be the DB for "qualified" retirement plans, including 401-k plans, unless that right is specifically waived in writing.
We always recommend that the designations be reviewed in the event of any major life change, such as marriage, divorce, death, or retirement.

It is also a good idea to check the designations every year or two, even if no life change has occurred, to ensure that what was previously designated remains in place. We frequently hear about accounts for which a DB and CB were properly designated but for which the custodian has, for whatever reason, lost track of the designation. The owner of the account can correct such errors while he is alive. The family members who are disappointed after he dies cannot do so.

Effect of the OBBB

The per-person exemption equivalent for estate and gift taxes has been increased to $15 million, and will continue to be indexed. That is an...